(In On a silver platter: CD-ROMs and the promises of a new technology)
- Video games seem to restructure/reorganize perception (driving like a game example)
- New frameworks for interpreting, understanding, mapping the real world
- Games are still new, not yet codified/familiar ("killer apps," rapid technological advancement and demand for novelty)
- Always-ideological ways of seeing -> presented in a fresh light? Radical possibilities?
- Civilization combines radical challenge and conventional ideological assumptions
- Omnipotent, almost omniscient leader-god with many roles (although, all the roles are essentially the same - resource management)
- "Internalize the logic of the program" -> teaches systems of thought -> identify with the computer (I might argue that these systems of thought are already internalized)
- Neither competition nor collaboration: synthesis, being-with, melding
- Immersion as being an extension of the machines (not the other way around)
- Cybernetic circuit/feedback loop
- Player is integrated into the system
- Simulation games create the opportunity to think through/reflect on what it means to be a cyborg
- New kinds of stories based on geography, space (encounter, transform, master spaces) Jenkins and Fuller, "spatial stories"
- Transform places into spaces (Heideggerian summoning forth of nature as standing-reserve?)
- Ther eis never a personal, subjective "tour" experience of Civilization's spaces (it remains abstract)
- "The story of the map itself" (ie: the system itself) -> not just an environment, the hero also
- Maps (and charts, graphs, etc.) are collections of subjective judgements in which subjectivity is ideologically erased (objectivity, scientific "god's-eye view")
- Does the technological aura of computers enable this erasure?
- Felxibility of multiple strategies (war, technology, etc.)
- Underlying truth that "global co-existence is a matter of winning and losing"
- Abstractness oversimplifies the complexities of imperialism, colonialism, etc.
- Transhistorical conceptions of science, religion, nation, etc.
- Purely functional role of religion and the humanities
- Scientific determinism
- Absence of hybridity -> nationalistic destiny (later versions of Civilization mediate this somewhat with the addition of Culture as a quantifiable gameplay element, but this carries with it another set of ideological assumptions)
- Possibility of transcending these assumptions through play -> mastery requires an understanding of how the system works (But can't this "understanding" just as easily take the form of precisely the same transparent, implicit, normalized ideological truth that Friedman suggests it might help to transcend?)
August 31, 2010
Ted Friedman, "Civilization and its Discontents: Simulation, Subjectivity and Space"
August 30, 2010
William Uricchio, "Simulation, History and Computer Games"
(In Handbook of Computer Game Studies)
- Sierra's Grand Prix Legends - demands for historical accuracy from fans, source of pleasure
- What are the claims and implications of historical games?
- Interaction between present-day player and representation/simulation of historical moment challenges fact/fixity
- Tension between the ludic and documentation (specific vs speculative)
- How do human subjects encounter textualizations of the past/how are they "written into" the past -> "interactions with the process of historical inscription"
- New ways of understanding history and historiography
- Two extremes of historical computer game approaches - specific events (accuracy, structured by re-created conditions) and historical process (abstract, simulation games, long-term historical development, structured by historical principles/ideology)
- Both extremes paint historiy as a multivalent process, many possibilities, interpretations, outcomes
- Some parallels to filmic representations of history, but the crucial difference is that games also simulate process
- Poststructural turn in history -> historical endeavour as play ("what if?")
- Destabilize heirarchies, subvert master narratives
- Some historical games value both accuracy and opportunities for creative intervention -> play emerges in the space between detail and improvisation
- Non-specific simluation-oriented games are less detailed, more abstract, but encourage broader engagement with historical process
- Civilization: broad epochal development
- Actual complexity of lived historical events vs the mediated snapshot of representation (inevitably partial, deforming, delimiting and presentist)
- Poststructural critique of re-presentation (how?) and of authority/objectivity (by whom?) "question reality, question authority" (Berkhofer)
- Coincides with the new representational possibilities of computers
- How do historical games mediate the past? (As opposed to textual mediations)
- "History as time-bound meaning situated in an ever-changing present"
- Simulation as process guided by certain principles -> pedagogical application
- "Virtual history," speculative
- Problem of a fixed beginning to a historically-specific game (where does an event actually begin?) -> structuring assumptions branch into an array of possibilities (hindsight)
- Simulation approach allows radical reframing -> structuring assumptions about long-term historical development, "ideologically-positioned maxims," organizing principles
- Poblocki: Civilization as the history of the Western state (implicit and explicit)
- Historical games fulfil demands for historical reflexivity, subjectivity and possibility but adhere closely to historiographic status quo in other ways (working against the speculative "freedom" celebrated by the games?)
- Uricchio thinks they succeed more generally as a means of reflecting on the past
- What if historiographic epistemologies were used as structuring agencies for games? Explicit and reflexive rather than underlying assumptions (What would this look like? Civilization could be customized to follow a Hegelian or Marxist theory of history rather than a Heideggerian technological determinism?)
August 24, 2010
Simon Egenfeldt Nielsen, Jonas Heide Smith, and Susana Pajares Tosca, "What is a Game?"
(In Understanding Video Games)
- Half Life 2 vs poker (both games, so different)
- Importance of specific definitions (not a question of correctness)
- Political dimension to definition
- Wittgenstein: family resemblances (does not actively seek a common feature, uses arbitrary examples, problem of formal/informal games)
- Huizinga: magic circle (ideological agenda to protect play as valuable)
- As special context were specific rules apply, games are not unique (but does Huizinga ever say they are? Why does a definition have to identify specific, unique features? -> exemplification structure?)
- Different to say they are separate than to say they are unique in their separateness
- Castronova: maintain separation or else play will lose its appeal
- Ways games extend into the real world and are not separate: time investment, moods, communication of ideas and values, behaviour, direct impact such as buying in-game items
- Callois: play is voluntary, uncertain, unproductive and make-believe
- Agon/competition, alea/chance, mimicry/imitation, Illinx/vertigo (and many hybrid combinations)
- Paidia vs ludus (not entirely distinct)
- Arbitrary categories? Too blurry?
- What about open-ended/free-form play within rules (SimCity example)
- McLuhan: games are tied to and reveal the nature of culture, and release tention (but can also create tension)
- Bateson: games as meta-communication, communication about communication, play is not taken at face value, communicates its un-reality (link to fiction)
- Sutton-Smith: multifaceted nature of games, definition is determined by purpose
- Games emerge as societies develop
- Finite, fixed, goal-oriented
- "An excercise of voluntary control systems in which there is an opposition between force, confined by a procedure and rules in order to produce a disequilibrial outcome."
- Meade: make-believe as part of the genesis of the self
- Adopt temporary selves (different from animal play)
- Rules enable/require consciousness of other palyer's roles, integration into a group
- Internalize the generalized other
- Jenkins: game as popular/lively art, popular aesthetics, emotional impact (parallels to earlier popular media)
- Infancy argument, still banal, formulaic, but have potential
- Player control, feedback are central
- Parlett: games have ends and means (requires a winner)
- Suits: restrictive rules to inhibit progress towards a goal (ie: inefficient means)
- Crawford: representation, interaction, conflict, safety
- Representation and safety are debateable (abstract games, indirect consequences)
- Formal definitions of digital games...
- Salen and Zimmerman: system, artificial conflict, rules, quantifiable outcome
- Juul: rule-based formal system, variable and quantifiable outcome, different outcomes have different values, players exert effort, influence and are attached to the outcome, optional/negotiable consequences
- Attitude towards the activity
- Digital games do not always match the classical definition
- Formal definitions help identify biases in our understanding of games, clarify whether observations are unique to video games (again, why do they have to be unique? Surely games share many, many features with other things and phenomena, why should a definition have to entail uniqe features?)
- Pragmatic definitions, "tools for action" (not so much pragmatic definitions as game design philosophies... aren't there also pragmatic definitions that scholars use?)
- Meier's "series of interesting choices" is an aesthetic stipulation or personal philosophy, not so much a definition
- Hunicke, LeBlanc and Zubek: mechanics, dynamics, aesthetics (rules/code, gameplay, response); sensation, fantasy, narrative, challenge, fellowship, discovery, expression, submission
- Design tools, not an actual account
- Genre
- Wolf's ridiculous list
- Aarseth's series of genre variables that apply to all games to varying degrees (questionably useful)
- Genres are arbitrary, but create expectations, financial function of genre
- Some systems of genre are more consistent (based on one clear criterion)
- Nielsen et al suggest categorization based on a game's success criteria
- Problem: games without explicit goals -> special category, process-oriented games
- Action games: motor skill, hand-eye coordination
- Adventure games: thinking, solving, patience
- Strategy games: between action and adventure, distant role of the general/god (turn based is closer to adventure, real-time is closer to action)
- Process-oriented games: system to play with for entertainment (toy), player character within (closer to action/adventure), or control over the system (closer to strategy)
- Process-oriented games may still encourage certain types of play over others
- Simulation games (sub-category of process-orienteD) mimic concrete, real-world experiences, so SimCity and SimEarth don't count (uh...)
- Nielsen et al's system of genre is just as problematic as any other system, and is hardly consistent (what exactly is the clear, single criterion? Successful gameplay actions? Then why aren't Strategy games simply divided up between action and adventure? It seems like the categories are also defined by whether the player controls one singular character or commands multiple characters)
- Additionally, the categories are confusing because they use familiar generic language ("action game," "simulation game") but disregard some colloquial understandings of those terms
- As with virtually all other approaches to genre in digital games, Nielsen et al miss the point that genre is a meaning-making discursive construct, not an objective tool and should be approached as such
Simon Egenfeldt Nielsen, Jonas Heide Smith, and Susana Pajares Tosca, "Studying Video Games"
(In Understanding Video Games)
- Financial, cultural, aesthetic significance of games
- Is game research science? Methodologically not necessarily, but in terms of "systematic, rigorous and self-critical production of knowledge," it can and should be
- Raise our standards to gain academic credibility, rather than vilifying other disciplines and the academy generally for not recognizing game studies
- Renewal of interest in popular culture, scholars who grew up with games, growing complexity of games have contributed to the emergence of game studies
- Relationships with game designers are a unique feature of the field (but for how long?)
- Many appraoches to games tackle many different questions
- Game/Rules, Player, Culture, Ontology as the four main perspectives one can take on games
- Simulation community vs game studies community
- Formalist vs "situationist" (poor choice of words) groups within game studies
Simon Egenfeldt Nielsen, Jonas Heide Smith, and Susana Pajares Tosca, "Introduction: Games as a Field"
(In Understanding Video Games)
- Many are no longer satisfied with "passive" entertainment (weird place to start...)
- Distinction between pre-digital/digital games
- Survey most influential/important developments and perspectives in game studies
- Interdisciplinary variety
- Game studies still young, messy
- Unanswered questions: What is a game? Why are there games? Why do some people prefer certain games? How to games affect the player?
- "There is much to be done."
Michael Mateas and Andrew Stern, "Build It to Understand It: Ludology Meets Narratology in Game Design Space"
(In Worlds in Play)
- If game scholars are contribute to game design/the advancement of the form (why would they want to?), they must understand design, rather than only analyzing existing games -> explore the new territory they imagine in their theory (but why should they be imagining new territory?)
- Player agency as the heart of the tension between ludology and narratology
- Mateas and Stern created Façade to explore this tension
- Complexity of game design problems requires the construction of experimental games to map/discover new areas of game design space
- Existing games only represent a small fraction of the possibility of games, so game scholars need to speculate on and explore those spaces to truly understand games
- So, according to Mateas and Stern game studies should be guided by a hypothetical, imaginary gamespace that will somehow reveal to us what games truly are/will be as we explore it? That's dumb. Games are whatever they are at any given moment, and are changing constantly... why would we assume that the true nature of games are in it's hypothetical future development, and not in their actual cultural-historical contexts? And for that matter, why would we assume that games have a true nature that can be revealed by making new games? Absurd.
William Huber: "Fictive Affinities in Final Fantasy XI: Complicit and Critical Play in Fantastic Nations"
(In Worlds in Play)
- How does FFXI generate space/tasks of play and situate the player?
- Altman's genre theory: semantically fantasy, syntactically an MMO (why does everyone ignore pragmatics?!)
- Fantasy as a fictional geography for working out questions of race, nation, ethnos, etc.
- Playable as procedure in games (actualization)
- Fantasy as an episteme created by always-ideological processes of replacement, subtraction and augmentation
- In-game races reference real-world ethnicities, relationships (and hybridize)
- Mechanisms of complicity: relation between nation-state and aboriginal/subaltern enemies; conquest, dominance of regions in the game; necessity of coordinated efforts (ie: partying up) that overshadows individual choice/agency
- This inescapable complicity is revealed through backstories, etc., but there is still no "real" historical agency
- So where, then, is the critical play promised by the title? (Expansive gameplay could be an example of this.)